Click for site home
The Blog on alanarnette.com
Climbing the World to End Alzheimer's
Sep 232012
 
 8,156m (26,670'), Manaslu

8,156m (26,670′), Manaslu

A deadly avalanche occurred on Manaslu in Nepal at 4:30AM on Sunday, September 23 killing at least a reported 9 climbers with another 6 missing. Another 10 climbers were impacted but escaped. It occurred at the 7000 meter (22,960′) level with the slide hitting Camp 3. News reports say that most of the victims were Nepal, Spanish, Italian, German and several French. One Canadian climbers was in the missing.

There were about 25 climbers in the area at the time of the avalanche all preparing for their summit push. Reports from teams on the mountains say that the avalanche blast destroyed many tents at Camp 2 but there were no serious injures.

As always, be wary of many of the reports given it is still early, and details are often incorrect and many of the witness are in shock. No names are available.

There were 30 teams with about 231 members, climbing Manaslu, an unusually high number due to the closure of the China/Nepal boarder preventing teams from reaching Cho Oyu, popular for climbers to test themselves at high altitude or on training for Everest.

At 8,156m (26,670′), Manaslu has become a popular alternative to Cho Oyu after organizers have had difficult getting reliable logistics and permits to climb Cho Oyu. Being entirely within Nepal, the logistics are slightly easier although the climb itself is a bit more difficult. Manaslu is located in western Nepal about 60 miles northwest from Kathmandu in a very different region than Everest

Manaslu is known as one of the less technically demanding 8000m mountains and is viewed as a precursor for Everest much in the same way as Cho Oyu. But the weather is always difficult on Manaslu and 2012 has seen extremely deep snow with heavy snowfall all last week locking the teams down in their base camps.

There have been less than 350 summits but about 55 deaths making Manaslu a deadly climb. That said, 15 of those deaths were on a South Korean expedition in 1972 and of those, 10 were tragically Sherpa. For comparison, Cho Oyu has seen about 2000 people summit it with about 50 deaths.

Almost all the regular teams climbing Everest had expeditions on Manaslu this season. The deaths and injures seems have been mostly on European teams located at Camp 3. The following teams have checked in via their blogs:

  • IMG: all members safe at camp 2
  • Alpine Ascents: all members safe at camp 2
  • Mountain Professionals: all members and staff safe at camp 1 or base camp
  • Adventure Peaks: all safe
  • Jagged Globe: all safe
  • Himalayan Experience (Himex): all safe

This report noted that the injured had already been helicoptered to Kathmandu hospitals including several Nepal Sherpas, 3 French, and 2 Germans. The poor weather was returning last Sunday thus slowing rescue and recovery efforts. However pilots have reported locating bodies from the air.

More details as solid information is available. My sincere condolences to families, teammates and friends of the fallen.

The ramp, showing seracs and crown wall, Manaslu 26 September 2012 Photo: © Chris Groves,

The ramp, showing seracs and crown wall, Manaslu 26 September 2012 Photo: © Chris Groves

Update 5: Summary

The avalanche was caused by a large serac releasing above Camp 3 at 7,400m. This triggered a slab avalanche which hit Camp 3 directly and impacted Camp 2 with a severe wind blast. It appears that many of the 11 killed were in their tents, most sleeping, at Camp 3 around 4:45AM Sunday September 23, 2012 Nepal time.

The avalanche debris was spread from 7,400m to 6,300m. Rescue efforts started immediately with teams climbing up from Camps 1 and 2. Russell Brice reports on his recent blog post that he became a defacto rescue co-coordinator and called Kathmandu for helicopter assistance. A B3 high altitude helicopter from Simrik Air arrived at 9:45 and began evacuation of the injured climbers. There were 18 total flights that day with 14 evacuations. 31 people were caught in the avalanche. 8 bodies were recovered and 3 are listed as missing and presumed dead (see update 3.1 below).

The severity of the avalanche was driven by heavy snow the previous week, some reports put the snow depth at 6 feet of fresh powder.

The remaining teams are mixed in their plans with some individual members leaving, some entire teams (estimated at 10 or more), including IMG, AAI and Jagged Globe. Some remaining to continue climbing. However, reports mention difficult conditions on the upper mountain, with high winds and, of course, the fixed line will have to be reset or replaced.

My deepest condolences for the families of the victims, their teammates and friends.

Update 4.1

The search has ended Monday in Nepal for any survivors according to French mountaineering officials out of Chamonix. They stated that six of the victims were French nationals. If confirmed this would bring the death toll to 11. Jagged Globe reports that the avalanche was 300m wide and 1000m long,

Several teams remain committed to attempting a summit.

Phil Crampton of Altitude Junkies has posted a first person report from Camp 2 where he and his team were hit by the avalanche blast. Visit his site for a picture of Camp 2 after the avalanche.

Today the remaining bodies have been removed from the mountain by three different helicopters. Hopefully this is the end of the tragedy that struck us yesterday morning at 4.30 am. All of our team members and Sherpas are safe at base camp. Several of us suffered cuts, bruises and concussions but nothing serious. We consider ourselves very lucky indeed.

We placed our camp two in the same position as we have done on all our previous expeditions. The campsite is protected from avalanche debris by a large crevasse which collects anything that slides. Due to the force of this avalanche we were protected from debris but the blast from the huge slide destroyed our campsite.

At 4.25 am I was awake fiddling with a awkward sleeping bag zipper. I had just laid back down and then at 4.30 am I was struck in the head by some avalanche debris and then Kevin and I were catapulted around in the tent several times before coming to rest in a destroyed tent with myself ending up on top of Kevin. All of our eight tents at camp two were destroyed and all of the team members and Sherpas had the same experience as Kevin and I.

All of our team members and Sherpas acted amazingly in the situation. Everyone was calm and collected even though it was dark and many were without suitable clothing and footwear. We eventually collected all the gear we could find and in the end we were only one boot missing. Many of the team spent several hours waiting for us to retrieve their footwear before descending down.

A Sherpa who was swept down the mountain from camp three stumbled into camp two suffering from head injuries and frostbite as he was caught in the slide and descended without boots. We stabilized the Sherpa and requested a helicopter. We thought we were going to lose him at one point and I was given priority with evacuation over the camp three survivors who were stable. I am glad to say I spoke with the Sherpa this morning as he was about to board a helicopter for Kathmandu.

Update 3.1

More details from the Himalayan Times: Update- these names have been confirmed.

The deceased have been identified as French nationals Ludo Challeat, Fabrice Priez, Cathrine Ricard and Philippe Bos, Canadian citizen Domique Ouimet, Spanish citizens Marti Gasull and Cristine Mittermeyer, Italian citizen Alberto Magliano and Dawa Sherpa, a Nepali. Claude Belmsas, Thomas Grenier, Ralf Rieske, Andreas Reiter and Arnaud Manel were injured in the incident and were airlifted to Kathmandu. Two French nationals, Remy Lecluse and Gregory Costa, have been missing.

Update 2

Outside Magazine reports on Alpine Ascents lead guide Garrett Madison’s observations:

We found a massive debris field, and climbers who had survived the avalanche,” wrote Madison in an email. According to Madison’s count, the French team lost five members. The German Amical team lost one, the Italian team lost one of its climbers and a Sherpa, and British commercial outfitter Henry Todd’s Ice 8000 team is missing two climbers, and one Spaniard is confirmed dead. The names of the dead and missing won’t be released until family members are notified.

Update 1

This detail first hand report via EpicTV team attempting to ski Manaslu:

23 September, 2:21 pm – Just got a call from Glen Plake in Manaslu Base Camp who told me this: “I’m OK, a bit beat up; missing some teeth and a bruised eye but write in big capital letters, GLEN PLAKE IS ALIVE AND HE’S COMING HOME.

“It was a major, major accident. There are up to 14 people missing. There were 25 tents at Camp 3 [6800m] and all of them were destroyed, 12 tents at Camp 2 [6300m] were banged up and moved around. Greg and I were in a tent together, Rémy was in another. It was 4:45a and I was in my sleeping bag with my headlamp on reading my devotional when we heard a roar. Greg looked at me and said, “That was a big gust of wind,” then a second later, “No, that was an avalanche.” Then it hit us. I was swept 300 meters over a serac and down the mountain and came to a stop still in my sleeping bag, still inside the tent, still with my headlamp on. We all went to sleep with avalanche transceivers on so I punched my way out of the tent and started searching. I searched for 10 minutes before I realized I was barefoot in the snow. Greg had been using my down suit for a pillow and I found my suit, I found everything that was in my tent – camera, sleeping bag, ski boots. It was like someone had thrown my gear in the back of a pickup – but there was no sign of Greg. Rémy and his tent are nowhere to be found. The Dynafit crew [Canadian skier Greg Hill's team] were sleeping at a high Camp 2 and were immediately on site to rescue people. Sergio, Stephane, Doji our Sherpa – all strong alpinists – have all come up to search. We’ve done three searches but when the fog rolled in we had to call it off. It was a massive serac fall, probably 600 to 700 meters across. It’s a war zone up here.”

 

Climb On!

Alan

Memories are Everything

Alzheimer's Fact: Alzheimer's disease is the sixth-leading cause of death in the United States (source: Alzheimer Association)
Alzheimer's disease is the only cause of death among the top 10 in the United States that cannot be prevented, cured or even slowed

  23 Responses to “Avalanche Kills 11 on Nepal’s Manaslu – Update 5: Summary”

  1. I just learner about this tragedy today. I clicked on your website and saw you are doing the 7 Summits….I just happened to see this news about the avalanche at Manaslu…..very sad about the loss of life and injuries. I’m trying to make sense of what happened. I understand there was 6 ft of fresh powder but it sounds like the death toll was mainly due to the huge serac that was puulled down with the avalanche. Sounds like its a good idea to sleep in your powder suit with your boots on after a heavy snowfall. So sad….I wish China would open its border to Nepal in order to make Cho Oyu more accessible….what are they afraid of….also India and China need to learn to get along. Brings to mind a Beatles song…..

  2. I have updated this post with a summary of what caused the avalanche and what actions took place and more.

  3. Haven’t slept a wink all night, too much imagination. The death toll appears to be less than first reported but no help for the grieving families. My heart goes out to them and the difficult days that lie ahead. I too lost a friend to an avalanche on Annapurna which seems a long time ago now but the sadness never leaves you.

  4. I have updated my blog post with the latest. Click on this thread’s picture.

  5. I posted the names of the deceased on my blog. Very sad and due to a natural disaster. http://bit.ly/POQfPv

  6. Thanks for all the updates Alan! I had been following news all day too.. no news of the French yet.

  7. Really sad news… thanks Alan for the update…

  8. Terrible loss. Thoughts and prayers to all involved, their family and friends.

  9. Manaslu fatalities identified: 4 French, 1 Canadian, 2 Spanish, 1 Italian, I Nepal. 2 French remain missing bit.ly/POQfPv

  10. Alan,

    E-mailed Phil after reading his dispatch. So glad he is safe and his team is safe. Cannot explain the depth of grief I felt for the loss of so many climbers. Have been haunted all day.

    Thank you for keeping us updated.

    Cheri

  11. Been watching the news all day and every bulletin gives more sad news. They will be in my thoughts and prayers as I climb into my bed tonight.

    • Very sad Kate. Not a least bit of condolences to the families but it appears to be a natural event (avalanche) with climbers in the wrong place at the wrong time.It hit most while still sleeping in their tents. rip

      • The news is hard to take on board, such magnitude. As you say Alan it will only be a small condolence to the families that it was a freak of nature and not the climbers mistake. So sad this early morning 12.55am UK time.

  12. Just awful news; thoughts and prayers to all concerned.

  13. Manaslu avalanche update: details emerging, appears slide triggered by serac fall. Sadly a risk of climbing, not crowds, neglect.

  14. Alan’s update on avalanche

  15. I have updated my post

  16. Another sad reminder of how dangerous the mountains can be.
    Thanks for keeping us posted Alan.

  17. SO sad to hear this! Prayers being lifted up for family and friends.

  18. This is terrible. It’s been a very tragic year for climbers…

  19. how awful. My thoughts are with the families of these climbers

  20. What a tragic loss. My heart goes out to the families of these climbers.