Click for site home
The Blog on alanarnette.com
Climbing the World to End Alzheimer's
Jun 102019
 
Everest SE Ridge from Geneva SpurEverest SE Ridge from Geneva Spur

Three Indian climbers came home to celebrations and fanfare for summiting Mt. Everest last month but there was only one problem – they never got above Camp 3 at 23,000-feet, much less on the summit at 29,035 feet.

Vikas Rana, Shobha Banwala, and Ankush Kasana all from villages in Northern India, were climbing with the Nepali guide company, Prestige Adventures, along with six others members. They claimed to have summited on May 26 when there were no other climbers on the summit. When asked the names of their four sherpas, they could’t recall their names according to a report in The Himalayan Times.

According to my own records of the 2019 season, there were no summits on May 26 due to high winds.

windlevelsgfsEVT-1.png

Not the first time

In 2016 Makalu Adventures admitted they helped Indians Dinesh and Tarkeshwari Rathod alter their summit photos to show them on Everest’s summit when in fact they never summited.  They were banned from climbing in Nepal for 10 years.

The spring 2019 climbing season on Everest has seen a record 77 climbers from India, up from 58 in 2018. Many hired low-cost Nepal guides that didn’t provide the appropriate support for the limited experience level of their customers. 

Of the 11 deaths on Everest this spring, four were from Indian and all with low-cost guides that charged half of the median price or around $30,000. Similarly four of the  additional 10 deaths on other 8000-meter peaks including Makalu, Lhotse, Cho Oyu and Kangchenjunga were also Indian citizens.

Indian citizen, Amit Chowdhury, a veteran of numerous Himalayan mountaineering expeditions and received the Tenzing Norgay National Adventure Award in 2014 for his lifetime contribution to Adventure Sports, was quoted on May 24, 2019 in The Times India that there are too many incentives that are encouraging Indians to attempt Everest without the proper experience. He went on that:

“It’s great to be garlanded in your local area by your local Member of Parliament, among a group of equally ignorant folks and show picture of you proudly standing on top of Everest and with the National Flag and perhaps land a Government job or get promoted from constable to a Sub-Inspector. If you are lucky and get some backing from a politician you could even land yourself an award or a plot of land. It’s not cool, however, if you say you climbed a previously unclimbed route on 6,485 metre high Brammah II.”

Limited Vetting

Oddly, the Nepal Ministry of Tourism said they had interviewed the three climbers and had accepted their summit claims and were preparing their summit certificates. The standard procedure is to produce a photograph of a climber standing on the summit with a clear view of their face. Apparently these three didn’t have any proof and the Ministry simply took their word.

The government appointed “liaison Officer” who is charged with monitoring a team for rules compliance and to validate their summit was only at base camp for two days and was not there on their alleged summit date, yet he had authorized that they had summited.

It seems that India has a problem with those hoping to climb Everest. Perhaps it lies with incentives and the myth that they will become rich and famous.

Indian climber Kuntal Joisher who has summited from both the Nepal and Tibet sides would disagree that an Everest summit is a path to fame and fortune and goes on suggest:

I get 100s (if not more) messages throughout the year from people aspiring to climb Everest – and my advice to all of them is 3 fold:

  1.  Build superman level physical fitness.
  2.  Do a basic and an advanced mountaineering course.
  3.  Work on mental and emotional fitness.

Climb On!

Alan

Memories are Everything

  5 Responses to “Everest 2019: Indians Fake their Summit Claim”

  1.  

    Alan- this seems like more evidence of the pressure on people from India to summit Mount Everest. The quote from the reknown Indian climber show’s that people may gain material benefit from summiting, which makes it much more than a personal or charitable quest.

    I don’t think Everest will improve and I think we will just have to get used to more deaths of inexperienced climbers. Sad as it makes me to say it, the willingness to change isn’t there while the willingness to let people die seems to be part of the culture.

    •  

      For Indians serving in various government agencies(police, fire, etc… excluding Armed forces as they have their own climbing programs and they are genuine) using the claim of having climbed Everest is used a a tool to gain promotion and higher pay scales. Fake claims aren’t particularly new, last year or year before that a couple of Maharashtra Police was caught of faking the summit bid on Everest.

  2.  

    Seems fairly evident some cash must have changed hands here….

  3.  

    Hi Alan, what happens from here then – are they allowed to keep their summit certificates, regardless of the fact that it is untrue, simply because the Ministry and “liaison Officer” assumed? Seems quite a cheap win, in my books! Surely there should be some sort of further investigation into allegations of a false summit. Also really unfair to those that did actually struggle to the summit and back. Anyway, I suppose in reality they have to live with themselves being fakes and cheats.