Click for site home
The Blog on alanarnette.com
Climbing the World to End Alzheimer's
Sep 292021
 
Manaslu 2013

As we get near the end of the Manaslu season, there are more summits piling up, well over 150 now, and sadly one death, but controversy abounds over who really summited. The weather took a turn for the worse holding some teams at C3 or C4 but they are pushing back up now. Also the push is on at Dhaulagiri and soon on Kangchenjunga.

The Summit Circus

The Manaslu season has been marked by real confusion over what constitutes the true summit and who historically and currently reached it. As usual Mingma G is at the sharp end of the stick as he was with his claim he summited Nanga Parbat and Broad Peak in 2017. He went back later to summit to both peaks to clear any confusion, a sign of true integrity.

Manaslu’s (and Annapurna, Dhaulagiri, and other’s) summit definition and controversy is not new, it’s been fueled by purists for the past several years. For Manaslu, the issue is the last few meters to the summit is across a heavily corniced snow ridge that is virtually impossible to place protections (ice screws, pitons, etc) to protect climbers from crossing it.

So this year, Mingma, building on his winter K2 success, wanted to make a point. This time he proved he made his true summit with the help of drone pictures and videos he shot. Instead of crossing the corniced ridge, he is shown taking a drop-down route across a 70-degree face then climbing to what apparently is the true summit. It appears genuine. Then all the other climbers who claimed a summit this season without following his path will be noted as reaching the fore-summit.

While impressive, his summit has called into question years of previous summits with little evidence to claim they didn’t reach the true summit. Each year, the snow conditions are different so to make a blanket claim that this is the first one since, fill in the year of your choice, feels like a bit of a stretch to me.

The climbing community can be quite judgmental at times, for example calling the use of supplemental oxygen, “doping.” Or having Sherpa support on a climb, “not real climbing.” Some are now calling everyone who didn’t follow Mingma’s lead, “cheaters.” For decades, the well-respected Elizabeth Hawley of the Himalayan Database used common sense to “award” a summit if the route conditions very close to the summit were deemed too dangerous to traverse. She understood that standing ten feet higher was not worth risking your life.

There are no prizes for summiting unless your sponsorship is based on it or you are trying to set some kind of record like summiting all 14 8000ers in the fastest time, and that has lead to fraudulent claims in the past. Christian Stangl‘s K2 fraud comes to mind.

I fully support transparency at every level and that often comes down to personal integrity. If you reached a point commonly considered as far as you can go within reasonable risk, then that’s “your” summit. Of course, that point has to be extremely close to the “true” summit, extremely close. If you want to take the chance, and conditions are right to take more risk, then go for it. It’s a personal decision, but please don’t ostracize others for not being in the right spot at the right time. And those who get to their “summit”, please don’t claim you stood on the tippy top, own what you did with pride.

This New York Times article is full of quotes from famous people discussing this controversy. For example, Ed Viesturs is quoted, “I don’t know. I mean, who’s counting? Who’s watching? Who’s paying attention?” And Messner with “If they say maybe on Annapurna I got five meters below the summit, somewhere on this long ridge, I feel totally OK. I will not even defend myself. If somebody would come and say, this is all bullshit what you did? Think what you want.” The article is well worth a read, especially before making a comment 🙂

Before people ask me in the comments about my 2013 Manaslu “summit,” I was told by Everest record holder, Phurba Tashi Sherpa, Russell Brice’s long time Sidar who fixed the ropes that year, that we reached the true summit and the high spots behind were accumulated snow, not rock. That has always been good enough for me. However in looking at my photos, it appears we stopped at the last bump before “Mimgma’s summit.” And you know what? I’m fine with that.

2013 Manaslu

2013 Manaslu “summit.” Photo by Alan Arnette

Manaslu – Summits

8K Expeditions had a golden season with 21 climbers on top:

1. Bhagwan Bhikoba Chawale – India
2. Dawa Ongchu Sherpa – Nepal
3. Jose Armando Navarrete Ulloa – Mexico
4. Lakpa Thendu Sherpa – Nepal
5. Pema Chhiring Sherpa – Nepal
6. Gina Cleopatra Badescu – Romania
7. Tshering Pemba Sherpa – Nepal
8. Zeng Xiaoyun – Singapore
9. Dawa Wongchu Sherpa – Nepal
10. Song Yujiang – China
11. Dawa Dorchi Sherpa – Nepal
12. Christian Alfred Julius Kober – UK
13.Mohammadmoen Abbasi Nisar – Iran
14.Pemba Rita Sherpa – Nepal
15.Liliya Ianovskaia – Canada
16.Pemba Dorchi Sherpa – Nepal
17.Narayanan Iyer – India
18.Nawang Sherpa – Nepal
19.Mohammad Javad Akbari – Iran
20. Narbin Magar – Nepal
21. Tanya Louise Perret – UK

Seven Summits Treks, the largest operator on Manaslu reported more 30 summits on top of their previous 24:

1: Jonathan Duke Ruane 🇮🇪
2: Nadhira Al Harthy 🇴🇲
3: Kastrui Savekar 🇮🇳
4: Jitender Ramdas Gaware 🇮🇳
5: Gerhard Klaus 🇩🇪
6: Katayoun Mahmoudifar 🇮🇷
7: Benito Tompot 🇳🇱
8: Klaus Bohme 🇩🇪
9: Venkata S. Bhojanapalli 🇮🇳
10: Dauren Nurmukhambetov 🇰🇿
11: Ilia Kenigshten – Ukraine 🇺🇦
12: Oleg kriyanov 🇷🇺
13: Stanisloves Visniauskas 🇱🇹
14: Volodymyr Rosko 🇺🇦
15: Anna Tybor 🇵🇱
16: Marco Majori 🇮🇹
17: Federico Secchi 🇮🇹

Sherpa Team:
1: Furtenji Sherpa 🇳🇵
2: Dorchi Ongdak Bhote 🇳🇵
3: Pemba Thinduk Sherpa 🇳🇵
4: Pasang Sherpa 🇳🇵
5: Nima Dorchi Sherpa 🇳🇵
6: Furtenji Sherpa 🇳🇵
7: Ngima Sherpa 🇳🇵
8: Furba Kusang Sherpa 🇳🇵
9: Redak Bhote🇳🇵
10: Pem Nurbu Sherpa 🇳🇵
11: Phurbha Sherpa 🇳🇵
12: Doma Chhirring Sherpa 🇳🇵
13: Tashi Sherpa 🇳🇵

Tendi Sherpa leading the Climbing the Seven Summits team status is unknown, they are quiet with the death of a member. Kobler & Partner and Makalu Extreme claimed summits but no details. Furtenbach Adventure‘s team is on the move and should top out the morning of September 30.

Death On Manaslu

The fallen is Canadian Brent Seal, 37, climbing with TAG Nepal/Climbing the Seven Summits. source Cause of death was reported as a stroke or heart attack. My sincere condolences to his family, friends and teammates.

Dhaulagiri – Summit Push Underway

The fixed ropes are to 7500-meters on this 8167-meter/26,795-foot peak. There are four teams with 40 foreign permitted climbers including 83-year-old Carlos Soria Fontán which is his 12th attempt. He was last reported on his push at Camp 1. If the weather holds, they will go for the summit the night of September 29/30.

Several Manaslu climbers are on the Dhaulagiri including Jon Gupta with his client Becks Ferry. They are trying to summit seven 8000ers this season. They have Everest, Lhotse, K2, Manaslu thus far and now are on Dhaulagiri. Also directly off Manaslu is Pakistani is Shehroze Kashif who is aiming for all 14 of the 8000ers. He now has four. He is the youngest climber to summit K2 on 27 July 2021 and the youngest Pakistani to summit Everest on 11 May 2021.

Kangchenjunga – Progress

Over on Kangchenjunga, the Alpenglow team said they are ready for the summit push. They gave details on their team:

  • @estebantopomena : 10 total 8,000m summits; Everest 4 times (1x no O2), Cho x4 (1x no o2), Manaslu no O2, K2⁣⁣
  • @carla.perez.ec : 5 total 8,000m summits, including Everest 2 (1x no O2), K2, Cho Oyu, and Manaslu, all without O2.⁣⁣
  • @blackjanwerner : Cho Oyu w/ Alpenglow⁣⁣
  • @dorjisherpa : 26 total 8,000m summits; 19 Everest summits, 3x Cho Oyu, and 4x Manaslu summits⁣⁣
  • @mingma143 : 23 total 8,000m summits of 8,000m peaks; Everest 15x, Cho Oyu 5x, and Manaslu 3x.⁣⁣
  • @namgye : 21 total 8,000m summits; 11 Everest summits, 4x Lhotse, 3x Cho Oyu, Annapurna, Manaslu, and K2⁣⁣
  • @pembageljesherpa : 8 total 8,000m summits; Everest x5, K2, Kanchenjunga, and Manaslu.⁣⁣
  • @pasangcrp123 : 5 total 8,000m summits; Everest x3, Cho Oyu x2.⁣⁣

Topo gave this update on their plans:

So grateful and excited for all that we got done last week! We fixed ropes up to C4, moved oxygen to the higher camps and progressed in the acclimatizing process. We still have until the end of October here but thanks to the hard work and good fortune we’ve had with the weather and conditions in the past rotations, now we’re thinking that the time for a summit attempt is the right move! 🔥In the difficult game of climbing big mountains one has to be ready to wait weeks sometimes for the right moment but also in order to keep the doors open is important to take and try to make the best out of any opportunity that might come one’s way. 🎯Let’s see if the weather and conditions align and we can get on top the next time that the skies are blue! For now, a few days of popcorn and movies with some of my favourite human beings is not a bad plan!

Climb On!
Alan
Memories are Everything

Comments on/from Facebook

  10 Responses to “Autumn 2021 Himalayan Season: Who Really Summited Manaslu this Year?”

  1.  

    What Summit did Anna Tybor ski from?

  2.  

    What a spat Who is Damien? I’ll keep on reading and enjoying !

  3.  

    Alan, Thank you so much for taking the time to write up these blog posts. I’ve been a reader for years and your content is how I keep up with what’s going on in the sport. As with any endeavor, there’s always someone who’s not going to agree with what you’re doing and communicate that displeasure with a lack soft/interpersonal skills. Keep in mind, however, for every one of those people there is hundreds whom read your content and appreciate all that you do. Keep it up my friend!

    •  

      Thanks, Christopher for the kind words and support. I’ve strived to be objective, factual, objective, and informative since I started my blog over 20 years ago. I make many comments based on my experience to provide context for what others are experienceing. I rely on first-hand direct reports as well. Of course, everyone is different and I respect that plus the perspectives of knowledgeable observers. When I get it wrong, I try to correct discrepancies quickly and with candor. That said, I know the mountaineering world has quite a disparate set of personalities thus there will always be different viewpoints.

  4.  

    Wow! Calm down Damien! Though you are obviously a very passionate follower of mountaineering, you have a vitriolic attacking style of getting your point across. I’d take more notice of you, if you debated the facts rather than attack Alan.

  5.  

    Damien Gildea, no need for personal attacks. Life is too short. No one needs the drama these days, and it is disappointing to see you speak so hatefully to a fellow mountaineer. Alan does his best to report on expeditions, if you don’t like his perspectives, don’t read his blog. For many years I have been able to follow my international friends expeditions through Alans blog, whether they are guiding or climbing, and the reporting has been informative. I find that he is also open to rational differences in opinion. Thank you.

  6.  

    You’ll probably delete this, but anyway…

    You are wilfully misrepresenting the situation once again. I see you referenced and linked to Horrell’s blog saying “..Mark Horrell did a nice job explaining this situation on his blog.” when in fact he did no such thing and completely misunderstands the situation, as you do. That blog entry was an embarrassing mess of incompetence and confusion. The summit is not visible in any of those images he shows.

    There has been no “real confusion” this season. The issue of stopping short has been around for years and written up in many outlets. The Groves drone video just makes it undeniably obvious what has been the situation all along. Your slimy doubt-mongering on this is either incompetence or dishonesty.

    Photos taken from the summit looking back along the ridge tops make it clear that it is the highest point, there is no doubt or confusion. They found it in 1956, they found it in 2012, and they’ve found it in post-monsoon too.

    What this lays bare Alan is that most of the ‘climbers’ going to these routes have no clue what they are doing. Like you. No competent alpinist would claim that the slope MingmaG climbed is 70 degrees. The drone video shows it is not.

    You are also egregiously misrepresenting the approach of Ms. Hawley in saying she would be OK with climbers stopping short like they do on Manaslu. She certainly was not and is famous for that. On Manaslu, it’s not “a few feet” – people have been stopping at the flags which are 20-30m horizontally away from the summit. Thin snowy ridges at altitude have been climbed for decades in the high mountains – just not by incompetent guided clients glued to fixed ropes.

    You have also VERY selectively pulled quotes from that NYT piece. Ed is being diplomatic, as ever, but the facts show he went back to Shisha to get the summit, and he knew of the stop-short situation on both Manaslu and Dhaulagiri. YEARS ago. He even mentioned it in reports. As to Messner – what would you expect him to say? He is protecting his legacy, the foundation of his fame and wealth, plus I addressed this issue of climbs like his in my AAJ piece.

    Oh and by the way, some years ago I made a screenshot of your claim to have “…almost climbed K2 in alpine style…” It would be hilarious if you weren’t still putting yourself out there as some kind of authority.

    You simply have no shame Alan.

Have a comment?