Click for site home
The Blog on alanarnette.com
Climbing the World to End Alzheimer's
Mar 222010
 

When are you too old to climb Everest; or too young? How about 13 or 80? Does age really matter anymore?

I don’t like to discuss age with respect to records because they are hard to prove and records are difficult to maintain plus there is no unified system to confirm the climber’s claims.

However, Nepal requires permits with birth dates so climbs from the south side are as accurate as the information provided.

The youngest person to summit Everest was in 2003 was Miss Ming Kipa, sick a Sherpani, discount 15 years-old.  She summited from the north since you have to be 16 to summit in Nepal – this is to protect the kids. The oldest? 76-year-old Nepalese Min Bahadur Sherchan, from Nepal on May 26, 2008 via the south side.

The Young

Courtesy of research this table shows the youth movement on Everest:

Climber
Nationality
Birth Date
Ascent
Age
Edmund HillaryNew Zealander20 Jul 191929 May 195333 years, 313 days
Jürg MarmetSwiss14 Sep 192723 May 195628 years, 252 days
Hansrudolf von GuntenSwiss12 Dec 192824 May 195627 years, 164 days
Chu Yin-huaChinese31 Mar 193525 May 196025 years, 55 days
Sonam WangyalIndian Ladakhi8 Jan 194222 May 196523 years, 134 days
Shambu TamangNepalese Tamang20 Oct 19555 May 197317 years, 197 days
Pema ChiringNepalese Sherpa17 Dec 198322 May 200117 years, 156 days
Temba TshiriNepalese Sherpa6 May 198523 May 200116 years, 17 days
Ming Kipa SherpaNepalese Sherpanilater 198722 May 200315 years, ??? days


The Oldest

The oldest was 76-year-old Min Bahadur Sherchan, from Nepal in 2008. Japanese Yuichiro Miura (the man who skied down Everest) is neck to neck with him being a few days younger. He has already summited twice and and wants to return in 2013 at age 80 for another attempt.

Announced for 2010,  80 year old Former Foreign Minister of Nepal, Mr. Sailendra Kumar Upadhyaya wants to attempt to set the age record. Tamae Watanabe of Japan is the oldest woman to summit Everest at age 63 in 2002.

The Average

With all this talk about extreme ages, the reality is the average Everest climber is in their 30’s. In 2005, I did an analysis based on the press releases from Nepal’s Ministry of Tourism, Culture and Civil Aviation of the ages of the guides, climbers and Sherpas who summited that year from the South side. Not every age or title was listed but there was enough information to get an idea.

2005 South SummiteersLeadersClimbersSherpas
Total83944
Average Age383432
Youngest242020
Oldest524748


2010

In 2010, there are a few Everest climbers to watch with respect to age. It seems that each country has an age race underway.

First up is Jordan Romero, the 13 year-old from Big Bear California. He has already climbed 6 of the 7 Summits along with his father, Paul. Clearly controversial at such a young age, you can read more at Backpacker and Outside about Paul and Jordan. They will climb unguided via the North side with their own expedition using a Kathmandu logistics company.

Of note was in 2009, two 17 year-olds summited. Johnny Collision with professional guide Damian Benegas and Johnny Strange with professional guide Scott Woolums thus establishing the low-end for American climbers.

Bill Burke set a high bar for the aging Americans with his summit last year at age 67. Bill, now at age 68, is back to climb not only from the North but then will move to the South for another attempt during the same expedition – a double summit with Asian Trekking. Nils Antezana, a US citizen who was born in Boliva summited in 2004 at age 69 but died on the descent.

In the UK, Bonita Norris is looking to summit at age 22. Bonita is climbing with Kenton Cool’s Dream Guides.

India’s 16-year-old Arjun Vajpai ing to join last year summit of 19-year-old Krushnaa Patil. Vajpal is climbing with Asian Trekking.

Finally, let’s not forget the planned climb of 80 year old Mr. Sailendra Kumar Upadhyaya.

Age Risks

Is there a risk in climbing to altitudes where the oxygen density is 1/3rd that of sea level? The short answer is yes. Multiple medical studies have shown decline in brain size and almost near-death symptoms in the most healthy athletes. In 2007, team of UK doctors from the Caudwell Xtreme Everest expedition conducted extensive research. It is unknown the impact on the youngest or oldest climbers.

For young climbers, the questions include brain development, judgment, maturity and skills. For older climbers, it involves health issues, speed and stamina.

Enablers

So why are we seeing such as large variation in age on Everest. Three reasons: infrastructure and opportunity plus the willingness of sponsors to push the limits.

The infrastructure on Everest, and many other 8000m mountains, make climbing accessible to many climbers with the right skills and resources. Equipment is significantly improved just in the past decade. Oxygen systems are more reliable and the routes are well understood and maintained – especially on Everest’s south side.

Note, that I have not said it easy – every climber, regardless of their age, must carry gear and put one step in front of the other from base camp to summit; and back.

With so many expedition operators offering logistical only services, the costs are relatively low so young climbers can afford it. Also, the filter for climber’s skills and conditions are not what they used to be. Historically, guides required a physician’s statement plus a resume showing solid experience at high-altitude before accepting a climber for Everest. Clearly this “opportunity” comes with increased risks.

Sponsors see value in promoting their brand with unique climbers. While the vast majority of sponsored are in their late teens and twenties; some are on the extreme youth end thus targeting a desirable demographic for today and tomorrow. Just look at snowboarder Shawn White’s career as an example.

Responsibility

However, high-altitude mountaineering is quite different than resort activities where staff and medical support is immediately available. Climbers often put other climbers at risk. So it is important to be on a team with reserve capacity to help out in an emergency. The responsible ones think through worst case scenarios and prepare for them with competent teams and support staff.

The older climbers are proving aging does not mean stopping and the youth are showing that under the right conditions, you can do amazing things at any age. I admire these “extreme” climbers. They are pushing the envelope of conventional boundaries and I wish them the of luck. But more importantly, to be safe and return home with or without a summit.

Climb On!

Alan

Comments on/from Facebook

  2 Responses to “The Right Age to Climb Everest?”

  1.  

    Dont get me wrong as anyone who think they have the skills can have a go at climbing Mount Everest but I personally think 13 is too young. Why the rush, just to become the youngest?

    Mount Everest The British Story

    Climbing News

  2.  

    Nice article Alan. Thanks for your solid analysis and great insight, as you always provide.