Click for site home
The Blog on alanarnette.com
Climbing the World to End Alzheimer's
Mar 092021
 
Guns at Everest Camp 2 in 2008

I had hoped that Nepal would let this spring season occur without the annual histrionics and propaganda of new rules, after all, isn’t dealing with COVID enough?

But, alas, the temptation was too great. It seems the photo of the line of climbers between the South Summit and Summit in 2019 cast a negative image on Everest (as it should have) and the Ministry of Tourism, MoT, always, without hesitation, tries to manage their reputation, even when the management itself comes across as silly.

The MoT posted eleven “new” rules only in Nepali on their website suggesting they really never intended for it to be taken seriously by anyone who does not speak Nepali. As usual, it feels designed for the mainstream press to parrot resulting in Nepal seen as properly managing their golden goose.

Most of the rules are not new and have been previously floated, and as always, never implemented or enforced.  These items are coming as climbers around the world are finalizing their plans and gathering COVID documents to enter Nepal in a few weeks. I’ve covered these annual public relations moves for almost a decade if you have the patience to read and read.

You Can Take a Picture, Just Don’t Share it!

Let’s start with the official statement from Mira Acharya, director at the Mountaineering Division of the Department of Tourism to the Kathmandu Post

Our law bans the dissemination of photos and videos taken on Everest without the department’s consent. But the practice has not stopped.

I wonder if she winked at the reporter when she said this? She went further if that’s possible:

Each climber can take, share and make images and videos of their group or of oneself but they will face action if they take, make and share photos of other climbers without the department’s consent. We honour the personal freedom of climbers but that does not mean they can post images and videos of others without their consent. Either through commercial cameras or mobile sets, all such activities have been banned.

Even longtime supporters and officers involved in managing Nepal’s trekking and mountaineering industry found the comment ludicrous. Ang Tsering Sherpa, former president of Nepal Mountaineering Association noted:

It’s not possible to prevent the dissemination of videos or photos taken on Everest because millennials stand out for their use of technology, and even the older generation has embraced digital life. You make a click here and in an instant, your photo goes around the world.”

Remember, all of this stems from a picture of crowds that seemingly embarrassed some government official. Nevermind that the root causes of the crowds were: short weather window, inexperienced climbers, unqualified “guides”, and record permits issued by Nepal.

Nothing mentioned in today’s new rules addresses any of these real issues. See my review of 2019 for more details including why so many Indian climbers are dying.

Crowds in the Khumbu Icefall in 2008

Get Names

Take this scenario. You are climbing in the Khumbu Icefall and take a picture of several people above you. You have no idea who they are but it’s a great shot of a legendary, or infamous place depending on your viewpoint.

The strict letter of this rule is that you need to ask the Mot and/or each person in your picture permission for you to post this great image on social media, a website, or use it in a slide show when you get home.

Right.

Other Updated Rules:

Among the new rules that came into effect on Tuesday, March 9, 2021, as described in the Post article:

  • Organizers must buy insurance coverage for the support workers by clearly mentioning their roles in the expedition.
  • All climbers applying for Everest climbing permits must also submit their medical reports issued by certified doctors to prove that they are in the physical condition to endure the hardship that climbing the highest mountain in the world demands.
    • “It’s a report, a proof to ensure that a person is physically and mentally fit to climb,” said Acharya. “Even if a person has cancer but he is mentally and physically fit, he can climb.”
  • All climbers need to submit their detailed itinerary before applying for the Everest climbing permits.
  • Submit the details including how they arrived back in Kathmandu from the mountain during the debriefing that takes place with the department officials after the end of the Everest climbing season
  • All agencies including helicopters and airlines should evacuate foreigners who become ill in mountains only to well-equipped hospitals.
  • A detailed report of the climbs of individual mountaineers mentioning the dates of their climbs, duration of their stay at the base camp, the route they used, and days they reached the different camps as well as whether they reached the summit or not. The detailed report should also mention whether the climbers used supplementary oxygen or not.

As you can see, these feel bureaucratic in nature and will in no way improve safety, ensure that only experienced climbers are on the mountain with qualified “guides.” In other words, nothing changes.

Himalayan Database

I use the Himalayan Database as my primary source of Everest summit statics. If you are climbing in 2021, they are asking you to fill in an electronic web-based survey. This replaces the time-consuming process of visiting each team in their hotel before the climb.  Please use this link to complete the survey. You can now download the HDB for free at their site.

Follow Along!

I have begun to create my annual team location table and tracking climber’s blogs (see sidebar). If you have a team not listed, please let me know and I will add them if I can track them. If you prefer not to be mentioned, please contact me.

I will post a few background articles and interviews between now and early April when the teams arrive at the base camps. If you would like to see anything special this year, post a comment or drop me an email.

Here’s to a safe season for everyone on the Big Hill, but only take selfies!

Climb On!
Alan
Memories are Everything

The Podcast on alanarnette.com

You can listen to #everest2021 podcasts on SpotifyApple Podcast, Breaker, Google Podcasts, Pocket Casts, RadioPublic, Anchor, and more. Just search for “alan arnette” on your favorite podcast platform.

 

 

Comments on/from Facebook

  3 Responses to “Everest 2021: Silly Rules Season Returns from Nepal Government”

  1.  

    Can’t believe it’s the start of another season, looking forward to all of your updates from the teams Alan.

  2.  

    Surely- thanks and wishing everyone a wonderful Everest season. I am from India and i can say for sure for Indians climbing everest it’s all about self glory….

  3.  

    Thanks Alan. I’ll be reading along as you post.

    Maybe the required physical fitness letter will help with safety? I think they may not be too hard to find from a willing doctor though.